Copyright thejournal
We need your help now Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open. You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough. If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it. One-off amount I already contribute Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you. An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more. Investigates Investigates Money Diaries The Journal TV Climate Crisis Cost of Living Road Safety Newsletters Temperature Check Inside the Newsroom The Journal Investigates Daft.ie Property Allianz Home The 42 Sport TG4 Entertainment The Explainer A deep dive into one big news story Sport meets news, current affairs, society & pop culture have your say Or create a free account to join the discussion Advertisement More Stories McDonagh appeared before the Court of Appeal today.Alamy Stock Photo Man appeals rape conviction against teenage relative, claiming 'bad temper' evidence was unfair Barry McDonagh argued that testimony about his violent temper created a prejudice during his trial for repeatedly raping his teenage sister-in-law. 5.06pm, 31 Oct 2025 Share options A 61-YEAR-OLD Cork man who repeatedly sexually abused his teenage sister-in-law has appealed his conviction, arguing that evidence about his temper had a “catastrophic effect” by creating undue prejudice against him. The man’s lawyers argued evidence given by witnesses about Barry McDonagh’s temper was “irrelevant” and “highly prejudicial”. Counsel for the Director of Public Prosecutions said the case raised by the defence was that McDonagh, who the court had already heard had beaten his wife to the extent that he had broken her ribs, “can’t get a fair trial because the jury know he has a bad temper”. McDonagh, of Avoncore Bungalows in Midleton, Co Cork, was found guilty by a jury of 17 counts of rape and one count of sexual assault following a Central Criminal Court trial in June last year. He was jailed for seven and a half years by Ms Justice Caroline Biggs in October 2024. The abuse occurred at the man’s home and at his business premises on dates between 1999 and 2000 when she was aged between 15 and 16 and staying with her sister and brother-in-law. Pamela Mitchell, 42, waived her legal right to anonymity to allow McDonagh to be named. The evidence at McDonagh’s sentencing hearing was that the first incident of rape occurred when McDonagh took his victim away for her 16th birthday. Instead of bringing her to the intended destination however, he took her to a B&B and raped her. The court heard she froze during this and the subsequent rapes and that she was in fear of McDonagh because she had frequently seen him lose his temper with other people. At the time of sentencing, McDonagh continued to maintain his innocence and remained married to his wife – his victim’s sister, who was in court to support him. Launching an appeal against his conviction at the Court of Appeal today, McDonagh’s senior counsel Colman Cody argued the evidence about McDonagh’s temper was “irrelevant” and “highly prejudicial”. He said “temper evidence” had already been given by Pamela Mitchell prior to an application by the State to adduce further details from other witnesses. Part of Ms Mitchell’s evidence, he said, related to claims of an assault on her sister – McDonagh’s wife – which resulted in fractures to her ribs. He said there were inconsistencies in this evidence as the complainant had said she spoke to social services about the incident in 1999 but records showed the phone call was made in 2004. In relation to the additional evidence introduced, Cody said one of the allegations involved McDonagh throwing a motorcycle helmet which then smashed, another referred to broken glass in a door and a third related to an incident in which it was alleged the 61-year-old had thrown a chair at an oven door leaving a dent in the appliance. Counsel argued that the introduction of this “extraneous” evidence from others was “wholly irrelevant”. Advertisement Cody said the evidence was of such a prejudicial nature that it had a “catastrophic effect” and created extreme prejudice for McDonagh. He said the court, in its ruling, felt it was relevant and necessary because it related in some way to the complainant’s perception of McDonagh and how he would react if she were to try and stop what he was doing or report the incidents. “The fact Mr McDonagh may have lost his temper on other occasions, it has nothing to do with her perception,” said counsel. Another ground of appeal advanced was that the judge had erred in failing to discharge the jury following a question put to Pamela Mitchell which referenced a holiday to Tunisia. He said the question was “brief” but “loaded” because it implied that something had occurred in Tunisia. Cody also submitted the jury’s verdict was unsafe and unsatisfactory in all circumstances. He argued there were a number of discrepancies in the evidence given by the complainant, including the timing of the rib fractures, and inconsistencies in sketches she provided of McDonagh’s bedroom and workshop. He said the sketch of the workshop contained modifications which were not carried out until years after the incidents were said to have happened. The sketch of the bedroom, counsel said, did not include a cot which would have been present in the room at the time. In response, Sean Guerin SC, for the DPP, said the defence argument was that “an accused person, whom the jury know has beaten his wife to the extent that he has broken her ribs, can’t get a fair trial because the jury know he has a bad temper”. “The real difficulty for him is that the other evidence in comparison to what has gone into the case has no prejudice for him at all,” said counsel. He noted the trial judge had ruled the additional evidence was inextricably linked to the complainant’s state of mind, particularly her fear and lack of resistance. Guerin said evidence of an assault on McDonagh’s wife had already been admitted with the defence’s consent. What was subsequently admitted was “no worse” and as a result there was “no prejudice”, he said. Counsel said additional testimony from the complainant’s sister, Michelle Mitchell, was important as she suggested a domestic incident may have occurred in 1999, potentially causing the complainant to confuse events over the years. Guerin said the question referencing Tunisia was “benign” and the judge was “entirely correct” not to discharge the jury. In relation to the discrepancies in the complainant’s evidence, Guerin said the differences were purely a question of “timing and recollection” 20 years after the event and that this was a matter for the jury to assess. Justice Peter Charleton said the three-judge court would reserve judgement. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Support The Journal Fiona Magennis Send Tip or Correction Embed this post To embed this post, copy the code below on your site Email “Man appeals rape conviction against teenage relative, claiming 'bad temper' evidence was unfair”. Recipient's Email Feedback on “Man appeals rape conviction against teenage relative, claiming 'bad temper' evidence was unfair”. Your Feedback Your Email (optional) Report a Comment Please select the reason for reporting this comment. Please give full details of the problem with the comment... barry mcdonagh Court of Appeal News in 60 seconds ryan gibbons Murder investigation launched after man dies in hospital following assault in Kildare town 23 mins ago 'A stunning fall from grace': Court hears complex deception by DJ Carey continued for years Eimer McAuley 16 mins ago Newshound Quiz The Journal Friday Newshound Quiz 10 mins ago Just one Premier League match on St Stephen's Day this year 24 mins ago political block Surveillance at Stormont increases after ‘deliberate’ flooding of toilets 34 mins ago Sarah McNally Man pleads guilty to manslaughter of Longford woman Sarah McNally in New York bar Running wild Opinion: Halloween now doesn't hold a candle to how we did it in the 90s IPAS SYSTEM Family should be allowed home to Kerry after being moved 140km away, community leaders say Andrew Mountbatten Windsor UK's King Charles strips Andrew of his prince title and royal accommodation Former Kilkenny hurler DJ Carey remanded in custody pending sentencing on Monday for fraud charges SPOOKY FORECAST Trick or treating? Met Éireann has issued a thunderstorm warning for six counties from 7pm more from us Investigates Money Diaries The Journal TV Journal Media Advertise With Us About FactCheck Our Network FactCheck Knowledge Bank Terms & Legal Notices Terms of Use Cookies & Privacy Advertising Competition more from us TV Listings GAA Fixtures The Video Review Journal Media Advertise With Us Our Network The Journal FactCheck Knowledge Bank Terms & Legal Notices Terms of Use Cookies & Privacy Advertising Competition © 2025 Journal Media Ltd Terms of Use Cookies & Privacy Advertising Competition Switch to Desktop Switch to Mobile The Journal supports the work of the Press Council of Ireland and the Office of the Press Ombudsman, and our staff operate within the Code of Practice. You can obtain a copy of the Code, or contact the Council, at https://www.presscouncil.ie, PH: (01) 6489130, Lo-Call 1800 208 080 or email: mailto:info@presscouncil.ie Report an error, omission or problem: Your Email (optional) Create Email Alert Create an email alert based on the current article Email Address One email every morning As soon as new articles come online
