Copyright Parade

Key Points Tim McGraw appeared without his signature style at daughter Audrey’s New York performance. Fans described Tim and Faith Hill as “unrecognizable” and discussed their casual appearance online. Tim’s new bald look has Faith’s approval: “The main thing is my wife loved it.” Tim McGraw fans called the country star “unrecognizable” after he ditched his iconic style during a rare outing with his wife, Faith Hill. On Thursday, Nov. 6, Tim and Faith attended their daughter Audrey McGraw‘s performance at the Silver Lining Lounge in New York City. 🎬 SIGN UP for Parade’s Daily newsletter to get the latest pop culture news & celebrity interviews delivered right to your inbox 🎬 For the occasion, Audrey, 23, rocked a lace crop top and sheer, lace pants, finishing the look with a trench coat and black boots. Faith, 58, donned a black turtleneck and black pants while supporting her youngest of three children. Meanwhile, Tim, also 58, opted for a gray sweatshirt and jeans—except, he wore a green beanie cap instead of his signature cowboy hat. On X, fans of the country music family reacted to the “Live Like You Were Dying” singer’s unexpected style switch-up with mixed opinions. One supportive commenter shared, “I am glad to see them out in public not giving AF about glam, being their natural looking self. It’s refreshing.” Another X user admitted, “I wouldn’t even recognize them… at least they show up to show support,” as a third declared that Tim and Faith were “unrecognizable.” Still, others noticed something off about Faith’s makeup, with one wondering, “Who is responsible for Faith’s lipstick? Could they not find her lips?” A different X user echoed, “What’s going on with Faith’s lips?” Recently, Tim debuted a major hair transformation when he debuted a bald head—and Faith approves of his new ‘do. “You know, it was one of those things I wanted to try, and I did it,” he said on the Sept. 17 episode of The Bobby Bones Show. “The main thing is my wife loved it. So, I think I’m going to keep it for a while.” McGraw added, “The problem is, it gets cold quick.” He previously swapped a cowboy hat for a beanie, sharing a photo of himself with his brothers to mark the loss of his Uncle Hank, whom he misses every day. Oops! We’re unable to load this content right now. View directly on Instagram In addition to Audrey, Tim and Faith, who have been married since 1996, share two older daughters, Gracie McGraw, 28, and Maggie McGraw, 27.