Copyright yen
The hall fell silent as the treasurer read the figure. "Balance... zero." For a second, no one breathed. The December payout day, the most anticipated meeting of the year, turned into a storm. We stared at the numbers projected on the wall, then at the empty cash box. The same box that once held envelopes thick with savings from our monthly contributions. "What do you mean by zero?" Zodwa, our oldest member, shot up from her chair. "Where is the money, Lindiwe?" All eyes turned to our stokvel chairperson, Lindiwe Khumalo. She sat straight, her face calm but pale. "I will explain," she said. Her words did nothing to calm us. Some members shouted that she had stolen the pot. Others threatened to call the police. Lindiwe asked for time. "Please, come with me tomorrow morning. I will show you everything." By then, the rumour had already spread through Tembisa. "They trusted her too much," people whispered. Even my own husband asked if I had kept copies of the bank slips. The next day, we followed her to a local school near Andrew Mapheto Drive. Children in blue uniforms ran past the gate. Inside the principal's office, Lindiwe opened a large plastic folder and laid out a minute book, stacks of receipts, and bank statements from a separate account. "These," she said, "are the records." The book revealed that she had invoked the "emergency aid" clause after Nandi, one of our members, died in July, leaving behind two school-going children. Lindiwe had used the stokvel funds to settle their expulsion fees and transport arrears. We stood there speechless as the principal confirmed it. Later that week, during an emergency AGM, the circle's anger melted into shame. We had called her a thief. Yet the records showed she had even added some of her own salary to cover the shortfall. Our stokvel began twelve years ago under a jacaranda tree in Tembisa. We were eight women who shared the same struggles: rising food costs, unreliable jobs, and dreams of financial security. What started as a grocery fund grew into a savings circle that paid for school fees, medical bills, and small business start-ups. Lindiwe became our chair because she was steady and organised. She worked as an administrative clerk at a secondary school and always kept receipts in order. She never missed a meeting and reminded us about deadlines like a teacher marking homework. By the third year, our contributions had grown to R80,000 annually. Each December, we shared the pot, celebrated with a braai, and started fresh in January. The stokvel was our pride: proof that ordinary women could build something reliable without banks or loans. Then Nandi joined. She was younger, full of energy, and sold school uniforms from her small stall at the taxi rank. We loved her spirit. But she struggled financially, often contributing late. When she fell ill, she begged us not to expel her. "I will catch up," she said. Lindiwe allowed it, citing the "humanity clause" in our constitution. By mid-year, Nandi died after a long illness. Her two children were left in debt to their private school. The rest of us attended the funeral and promised to "do something later." Then life carried us away. When December arrived, we expected our usual payout. Lindiwe sent a message asking for a meeting before the disbursement. We thought it was about planning the party. None of us imagined the pot would vanish. That morning, when the treasurer announced a zero balance, I felt my stomach drop. Every member looked betrayed. We shouted over one another, demanding explanations. Lindiwe kept saying, "It is not stolen. I will show you tomorrow." For years, we had trusted her with signatory power. She handled the deposits, withdrawals, and reconciliation sheets. Now all that trust felt like a mistake. That night, I lay awake thinking of Nandi's funeral, of her children sitting quietly beside her coffin. I remembered how we said, "Her kids will be fine." None of us had kept that promise. The next morning, ten of us met outside the school gates. The air was cold, our tempers still hot. Lindiwe arrived carrying a heavy plastic folder. "Please," she said, "let's go to the principal's office. You will understand everything." We followed her into the staffroom. The principal, a tall man with greying hair, greeted us and motioned for us to sit. Lindiwe opened the folder and pulled out a thick minute book with a worn blue cover. "This is the record of all decisions," she began. "Here is where I noted the emergency meeting after Nandi passed." She turned the pages carefully, showing our signatures from previous meetings, then pointed to a section written in her small, neat handwriting. Resolution 14: Temporary use of funds under the emergency aid clause for Nandi's children. Zodwa interrupted, "But we never voted on that!" "You did not," Lindiwe admitted. "I did it alone because time was against us. The school was about to expel them." The principal confirmed that he had received payments from her. "She even brought her own payslip to prove she could repay if the group objected," he said. The room grew quiet. Some of us began flipping through the receipts: bank transfers, stationery costs, and a transport voucher. Everything matched. Still, anger lingered. "You should have told us," said Thandi. "You made us look like fools." Lindiwe lowered her gaze. "I know. I thought it was better to act first than to let those children lose a term." The treasurer clenched her jaw. "So you became the saviour with our money?" Lindiwe nodded slightly. "If that is how it looks, then yes. But I kept records because I expected questions." Outside, children's voices drifted from the playground. Their laughter sounded like forgiveness we had not earned yet. Later that evening, we gathered for an emergency AGM at Zodwa's house. The mood was divided. Some demanded she resign and refund the pot. Others said her heart was in the right place. I was torn between both sides. Our secretary suggested calling an independent auditor. It was agreed. "If the numbers match her story, we move forward. If not, we press charges," Zodwa said firmly. A week later, the auditor came. He examined every page of the minute book, every bank slip, and every deposit. His report confirmed that the funds were used exactly as stated, down to the last cent. Lindiwe had even topped up R4,000 from her own savings. When we met again, no one spoke for a long time. The shame was heavier than the anger had been. "I only hid the book because I wanted to finish the payments before facing you," Lindiwe said softly. "I thought if the receipts were ready, you would see the truth faster." We believed her, but trust once cracked never feels the same. The auditor's report became our turning point. It revealed not just honesty, but an opportunity we had never seen before. Thandi, our secretary, was the first to speak. "Maybe the mistake was not what she did, but how we manage things." We realised our stokvel constitution was outdated. It had clauses written in 2012 when we were just a grocery club. The "emergency aid" rule was vague. There were no clear limits or oversight processes. Lindiwe's actions exposed a governance gap rather than pure wrongdoing. During the next meeting, we went through every rule line by line. The atmosphere shifted from blame to rebuilding. We agreed to formalise a sub-fund dedicated to educational emergencies, named the Nandi Mokoena Bursary Trust. The pot that had almost broken us became the seed for something bigger. Lindiwe stepped down as signatory and requested to serve as auditor instead. "Let someone else hold the pen," she said. The group voted unanimously to keep her involved. None of us wanted to lose her discipline or her heart. The following week, we opened a ring-fenced sub-account at our cooperative bank. The principal who had confirmed the payments became an honorary trustee. We drafted new reporting templates, appointed two external witnesses for every withdrawal, and agreed on quarterly reviews. By February, word spread through the community that our stokvel had turned its scandal into a scholarship. A radio station even invited Thandi and me to talk about it. "It started as shame," I said on air, "but it became service." We received messages from other stokvels asking for our new constitution format. Some even sent donations for the bursary. That March, three learners received their first set of uniforms and paid transport through the Nandi Mokoena Fund. The joy on their faces healed something inside us that no payout ever could. Lindiwe smiled quietly that day, saying, "Nandi would have loved this." And for the first time since the storm, the group laughed together again. Months passed, and our stokvel found its rhythm again. Contributions resumed, meetings filled with tea, laughter, and careful minutes. The new rules worked. Three people signed every payment, scanned it, and shared it on the group chat. Transparency became our new language. When we reviewed the bursary account at midyear, the numbers spoke loudly. Five children from Nandi's old neighbourhood had their fees and transport covered. Two of them were in high school, one aiming for engineering. Their guardian came to thank us during a meeting and said, "You women brought back their mother's hope." Lindiwe remained quiet most of the time, taking notes as an auditor. I could see the relief on her face whenever the balance reconciled perfectly. The wound was healing through structure. One evening, as we walked out of a meeting, she turned to me and said, "You know, being called a thief broke something inside me. But watching those children go to school fixed it again." Her words stayed with me. The stokvel became stronger than before. People in the community started treating us as a model of how women's groups could combine compassion with accountability. We even hosted a workshop for smaller circles on how to write constitutions and manage risk. During that event, a guest speaker from a cooperative bank said, "When governance meets grace, you build sustainability." The line became our new motto. We printed it on our minute book cover. At the end of that year, instead of the usual December payout, we agreed to roll over half the savings into the bursary. The decision felt mature, as if we had finally grown from a savings club into a social impact circle. When I looked around the room, I saw the same faces that had once shouted in anger now nodding with purpose. Zodwa said, "We did not lose the pot. We multiplied it." That night, I thought about Nandi's children, now walking proudly in their uniforms. I thought about Lindiwe, who had risked her reputation for compassion. And I thought about the minute book that had once been evidence in a near-crime but had turned into a record of redemption. Our story began with suspicion but ended in solidarity. The money returned in ways that could never be counted in rands alone. Looking back, I have learned that leadership is not only about policies and balances. It is about intent, transparency, and courage. Lindiwe's mistake was not stealing; it was acting without consensus. Yet her intention carried truth. She chose humanity over procedure, and that choice forced us to build a better system. In South Africa, stokvels are more than savings schemes. They are social safety nets where trust is the currency. When trust breaks, poverty deepens. But when trust is rebuilt with honesty, it becomes wealth beyond money. The experience taught me that women's leadership is often judged harshly. A man in the same position might have been praised for charity. We, however, called her a thief before listening. It reminded me that accountability should never silence compassion. Today, our group still meets monthly. The agenda always begins with "Minutes of the Previous Meeting," followed by "Update on Nandi Mokoena Fund." The minute book, once hidden, now sits proudly on the table. Each new entry feels like a prayer written in ink. Sometimes I watch the younger members take photos of the pages with their phones and smile. They are documenting our growth, ensuring no misunderstanding ever repeats itself. When I pass by Nandi's children on their way to school, I feel a quiet pride. Their backpacks are heavy with books we helped buy, but their steps are light. The stokvel that once faced ruin now sponsors futures. If you asked me what changed us, I would say it was one woman's courage to act and another group's courage to forgive. So I ask you, reader, a question I often ask myself: when faced with a rule and a human need, which will you honour first? Because sometimes, doing what is right does not look right at first. Yet when truth is written clearly, even a minute book accused of hiding theft can become a ledger of hope. This story is inspired by the real experiences of our readers. We believe that every story carries a lesson that can bring light to others. To protect everyone's privacy, our editors may change names, locations, and certain details while keeping the heart of the story true. Images are for illustration only. If you'd like to share your own experience, please contact us via email. Source: YEN.com.gh
