STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Connecticut is claiming title of the pizza crown. But steadfast New Yorkers have just one thing to say: nice try.
Pizza has long been a staple of American life — a universally loved, endlessly adaptable comfort food. From kids’ birthday parties to late-night slices on the way home, it’s woven into the fabric of everyday life. And if there’s one place that’s been the true home of pizza in the U.S., it’s New York.
Time Out recently covered Connecticut’s push to claim the nation’s pizza crown. But a 2023 Lawnstarter study paints a different picture—ranking New York City the top “city for pizza lovers” by a wide margin.
According to Time Out, Barstool’s David Portnoy has declared that “Connecticut is the best pizza state in the country.” He praised New Haven-style pies, which he said are thin and coal-fired. Portnoy even described the classic New York slice as “floppy,” a far cry from the crisp, charred crust of its Connecticut cousin. However, some of the most iconic pizzerias in the country are spread across New York’s five boroughs — most of them family owned — highlighting the city’s everlasting pizza legacy.
From Lombari’s on Spring Street — widely recognized as America’s first pizzeria, founded in 1905 — to Mama’s TOO! on Bleecker Street, known for its square slices with light, charred crusts and creative toppings like pear and gorgonzola. There’s also L&B Spumoni Gardens on 86th Street in Brooklyn, famous for its upside-down Sicilian slices with a tender yet crunchy crust. Additionally, Luigi’s Pizza in Park Slope, which has served fresh ingredients atop simple pies for more than 50 years.
Connecticut may be making a push for the pizza crown, but New York’s history, culture and abundance of family-owned pizzerias keep it firmly on top.