Tensions were running high behind closed doors on August 28 when NASCAR Commissioner Steve O’Donnell met with team presidents to address a controversy that’s been boiling over, thanks to some eyebrow-raising text messages unearthed in the sport’s ongoing antitrust legal battle. Sources with direct knowledge of the meeting told Sports Business Journal that the lawsuit is more than just courtroom drama; it’s casting long shadows across the sport and fraying nerves at every level. Fast forward to yesterday, and what was meant to be a routine sit-down quickly shifted into damage control as officials were pressed to explain text messages that surfaced in the ongoing lawsuit.
At the heart of the storm? A no-holds-barred lawsuit brought by 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports that has NASCAR on the defensive, with a trial date set for December 1. During discovery, a particularly explosive message surfaced, quoting O’Donnell as saying the current charter renewal offer could come off as a “ f*ck the teams” deal. That one lit up the industry like a blown engine on the final lap. And cue the confusion.
Initial reactions painted O’Donnell as the villain, implying he was gunning for a raw deal that would leave the teams in the dust. But folks within NASCAR’s orbit are pushing a different story. According to insiders, O’Donnell wasn’t dishing out hostility; he was throwing up a warning flag.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
In an effort to cool the fires and clear the air, O’Donnell tackled the issue head-on during last week’s meeting. According to four people who were in the know, he stood firm, saying his words had been twisted and misread, and that far from selling out the teams, he was actually in their corner, fighting to get them a better deal. Still, the entire episode provides a raw look at the friction caused by the lawsuit and how it’s starting to rattle the cage of day-to-day business in NASCAR, which is usually a well-oiled machine. When asked about the conversation in the meeting, NASCAR stayed tight-lipped and offered no comment. And amid all this, the two teams involved, 23XI and FRM, filed for a summary judgment.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
It’s worth noting that this wasn’t one of the sport’s formal Team Owner Council summits; the TOC powwows include team owners and top brass. Last week’s gathering was a more intimate, mid-tier affair, limited to team presidents and a few NASCAR executives. 23XI Racing’s president, Steve Lauletta, was in the room.
Front Row Motorsports’ representatives were absent. Sources say GM Jerry Freeze had a scheduling conflict that kept him away, though the timing surely raised a few eyebrows given his team’s central role in the lawsuit. While the texts and legal drama grabbed the spotlight, other hot topics were also on the agenda, and one in particular got the paddock buzzing: the future of NASCAR’s playoff format.
NASCAR’s playoff format is still on the chopping block
According to multiple sources, some attendees walked away thinking a change is coming for 2026. But not so fast; others close to NASCAR’s internal discussions urged caution, saying nothing is set in stone yet. The speculation hit another gear when NASCAR spokesperson Mike Forde dropped a breadcrumb on the league’s in-house podcast, Hauler Talk. He confirmed that, yes, a playoff format change is on the table, and a meeting this week aims to narrow down the options. Still, sources say sessions are pending, and anything final is still around the corner. And now, amid Kyle Busch’s stone-cold take on the NASCAR Playoffs, hopes are still up to see changes in the current format.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
Internally, there is growing chatter that the current do-or-die, one-race championship format may no longer be the right fit. Some higher-ups are warming to the idea that a single-race shootout might not be the fairest way to crown a season-long champion, especially with loyal fans increasingly questioning whether the format reflects the full body of a driver’s work across the season. In oil, NASCAR’s high-speed world is grappling with more than just lap times and tire wear right now.
Between lawsuits, leadership messaging misfires, and the looming playoff overall, the off-season could bring as many plot twists as a short track Saturday night.