By Rohit Sarkar,We All Follow United

Copyright yardbarker

Journalist Pete O’Rourke has reported in Football Insider that Newcastle United remain highly interested in Kobbie Mainoo, having monitored his situation closely during the summer transfer window. Although the Red Devils blocked a move at that time, the Magpies are expected to return with an offer in January. United, however, remain firm in their stance and are unwilling to let the midfielder leave mid-season.

Adding further intrigue, Manchester City are also keen on the 20-year-old. Yet the real issue for United is not their determination to keep him, but rather how little he is being utilised under Ruben Amorim’s system. This lack of game time continues to fuel uncertainty around Mainoo’s future, despite the club’s insistence on holding on to him.

“We reported in the summer window that Newcastle were one of the clubs that were looking at Mainoo. So obviously, that interest hasn’t really gone away, and they will continue to monitor his situation at Old Trafford. United obviously blocked any potential move in the summer window because they felt they needed him, as they were a bit short in midfield as it is. I can’t see United being willing to let Mainoo leave again in the January transfer window.”

Why Manchester United must act decisively

As a fan, it is difficult not to feel conflicted. On one hand, Manchester United cannot afford to lose a talent like Kobbie Mainoo permanently; on the other, keeping him as nothing more than a squad option with limited opportunities risks wasting his potential. Since Ruben Amorim’s arrival, he has started just 12 of 30 Premier League games, and this season he has featured from the outset only once in three matches across all competitions. For a player already recognised by England, such treatment feels increasingly unjust.

Refusing a loan move in January is only defensible if Mainoo finally earns consistent starts. Amorim has based his philosophy on a 3-4-3 that often shifts into a 3-4-2-1, but that structure leaves little space for a midfielder of Mainoo’s profile. The solution may be simple: adjust to a midfield three, allowing him to connect Bruno Fernandes with the deeper build-up while bringing balance to the side.

Mainoo’s composure, short passing, and ability to progress possession are qualities United desperately need and cannot afford to sideline. If Amorim persists with his current setup, he risks not only stunting Mainoo’s growth but also leaving the team without the consistency it craves. For the sake of both the player’s development and the club’s future, the manager must place greater trust in him, or risk losing more than a midfielder, but also a symbol of what United’s academy has always stood for.