By 49 Comments
Copyright news
Deals of the Week
11:25PMMonday, September 29th, 2025
In the know quiz
Set your local weather
Breaking News
Courts & Law
Courts & Law
Courts & Law
Courts & Law
South Australia
Western Australia
Northern Territory
Breaking News
North America
US Politics
South America
Middle East
UK Politics
Health Problems
Mental Health
Inspiration
Weight Loss
School Life
Restaurants & Bars
Food Warnings
Relationships
The Sealed Section
Family & Friends
Fashion Shows
Fashion Trends
Face & Body
Cosmetic Surgery
True Stories
Lifestyle Videos
Travel Ideas
Short Breaks
Food & Drinks
Destinations
North America
New Zealand
Middle East
Central America
South America
Travel Advice
Tips & Tricks
Accommodation
Australian Holidays
Northern Territory
South Australia
Western Australia
Travel Videos
Entertainment
Celebrity Life
Hook Ups & Break ups
Celebrity Photos
Celebrity Kids
Celebrity Deaths
Celebrity Style
Morning Shows
Current Affairs
Upcoming Movies
Movies Reviews
Music Festivals
Books & Magazines
Golden Globes
Entertainment Videos
Social Media
Mobile Phones
Home Entertainment
Archaeology
Environment
Climate Change
Sustainability
Natural Wonders
Motoring News
On the Road
Technology Videos
Cost of Living
How to Save
Salary Secrets
Personal Finance
Superannuation
Australian Culture
Power & Influence
Inside Parliament
Gig Economy
Breaking News
Manufacturing
Other Industries
Australian Economy
World Economy
Interest Rates
Federal Budget
Australian Markets
World Markets
Australian Dollar
Cryptocurrency
Real Estate
Sydney & NSW
Melbourne & VIC
Adelaide & SA
Cricket Live Scores
V8 Supercars
Sports Life
American Sports
Paralympics
Horse Racing
Expert Opinion
More Sports
Sport Videos
Sales & Deals
Home & Appliances
Health & Wellbeing
‘Making your own rules up’: New clip shows plot twist in NRL controversy
NRL great Braith Anasta has spotted the key moment Bunker officials would have paused footage before making one of the 2025 season’s biggest calls.
Daniel Ramus
September 30, 2025 – 7:01AM
49 Comments
Share via Email
Share on Facebook
Share on Whatsapp
Ouça este artigo
Copied URL to clipboard
codesports.com.au
Heated debate on Mam contact with Cleary
NRL: The NRL 360 crew couldnt agree around whether Ezra Mam deserved to be penalised for dangerous contact with Nathan Cleary.
Veteran reporter Phil Rothfield believes the Panthers should have been awarded a penalty for Ezra Mam’s contact on Nathan Cleary at a crucial stage of yesterday’s preliminary final.
With only 25 minutes remaining in the game and the Panthers leading 14-6, it appeared as though Mam had made contact on Cleary when he was in the air as he was putting in a kick.
But it was the Broncos who instead received the penalty because Panthers star Liam Martin ran in and became involved. Martin was fined $1000 over the incident.
Watch every game of the NRL Telstra Premiership Finals Series before the Grand Final, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play on Kayo Sports | New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1.
But closer examination of video footage on NRL 360 on Monday night suggested the officials in fact made the right call not to penalise Mam, given that Cleary’s foot was on the ground when Mam made initial contact with him, and therefore Cleary wasn’t tackled in the air.
But Rothfield felt the Panthers were hard done by.
“No question at all that he’s been tackled in the air while kicking the football,” Rothfield said.
“Penrith deserved the penalty. Absolutely they did.
Did the Panthers deserve a penalty for this moment?
“That’s a penalty. Tackled in the air. It is. I’ve spoken to the NRL about it. I’ve sent them the still frames.”
But host Braith Anasta had a different view.
“His foot’s on the ground. It’s a no penalty,” Anasta said.
“He tackled him exactly how you’re supposed to. He wrapped his arms around him and takes him to the ground.”
But Rothfield fired back at Anasta.
“I’ve talked you through the rules. You can’t tackle a man in the air. There he is in the air,” Rothfield said.
However, Anasta felt the footage told the story.
“We just paused it when his foot was on the ground and he was touching him,” Anasta said.
But Rothfield doubled down.
“Oh mate, it was that much. Come on,” he said.
“It doesn’t matter,” Anasta replied.
Rothfield reiterated his point.
“Mate, we’re not in the bunker. Seriously,” he said.
“That was an illegal tackle, mate.”
Copied URL to clipboard
codesports.com.au
‘Panthers shouldnt have rested players’
NRL: Brent Read says Penrith made a mistake resting players when the top four was still a possibility.
Anasta continued to make reference to the footage of the incident.
“The bunker would have looked at it and they would have paused it right here,” Anasta said.
But Rothfield had made his mind up.
“That was a dangerous tackle. I’m not changing my opinion. I don’t care what you’re stopping here. It was a dangerous tackle,” Rothfield said.
“Don’t worry about the rules. You just make your own ones up,” Anasta replied.
Originally published as ‘Making your own rules up’: New clip shows plot twist in NRL controversy
Join the conversation (49 Comments)
Add your comment to this story
To join the conversation, please
log in. Don’t have an account?
Join the conversation, you are commenting as
More related stories
‘Done nothing’: Club great rips into Storm star
Grand final week is off to a fiery start with a Broncos legend going after Stefano Utoikamanu for his “stuck up” comments.
NRL axes ref in bombshell GF decision
The NRL has made the shock decision to axe arguably the NRL’s most experienced referee after a horror show on the weekend.
NRL issue Ch9 please explain after shock act
The NRL is at war with Channel 9 after the Today show went rogue last week in the lead-up to the AFL grand final.
Registration
In The Know Quiz
Newsletters
Competitions
Welcome to news.com.au
Code of Conduct
Help and Support
General Feedback
Advertise with us
Standards of Practice
Licensing & Reprints
Our News Network
The Daily Telegraph
The Courier Mail
Our Partners
realestate.com.au
CODE Sports
A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content (including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and content more relevant to you on our network and other sites. Find out more about our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out.Sometimes our articles will try to help you find the right product at the right price. We may receive payment from third parties for publishing this content or when you make a purchase through the links on our sites.
Privacy policy
Relevant ads opt-out
Cookie policy
Terms of use
Nationwide News Pty Ltd © 2025. All times AEST (GMT +10). Powered by WordPress.com VIP
More stories before you go
