By Caroline Castrillon,Senior Contributor
Copyright forbes
“Job hugging” captures the trend of employees staying put for security in an uncertain market.
The era of job hopping, where ambitious professionals switch companies every two to three years to pursue better opportunities, appears to be fading. In its place, a new phenomenon called “job hugging” has emerged, where employees cling to their current positions. According to ResumeBuilder.com’s recent survey of 2,221 full-time U.S. workers, nearly half (45%) are now job hugging, staying in their current roles because switching feels too risky. This shift is driven by a combination of AI disruption fears, economic uncertainty and a cooling job market that has left many individuals questioning whether switching jobs is worth the risk.
But this dramatic shift raises a critical question: are professionals making a smart strategic move, or are they letting fear drive decisions that could limit long-term success? To determine which strategy pays off most, we’ll examine five critical factors that define career success: salary growth, career advancement, skill development, job security and employer perception.
Let’s weigh the traditional advantages of job hopping against the new realities job seekers face today.
1. Salary Growth
The Job Hopping Advantage
For years, job hopping has dominated when it comes to salary growth. Research consistently shows that external hires typically command 10% to 20% salary increases, while internal promotions average just 3% to 5% raises. Over a career span, this compounding effect can result in hundreds of thousands of dollars in additional lifetime earnings.
The Job Hugging Reality
However, the game has changed dramatically. With job growth slowing to just 22,000 positions added in August 2025 and unemployment rising to 4.3%, job hoppers have lost much of their leverage. Companies facing economic uncertainty are tightening budgets and becoming more conservative with salary offers. Organizations with stable workforces face less pressure to match outside salaries, keeping internal compensation growth modest.
MORE FOR YOU
The Bottom Line
Switching companies offers greater salary growth, even in today’s challenging market. While the risks have increased, the salary jumps from external moves still dwarf the internal raises that job huggers typically receive. Over time, job huggers trade long-term earning potential for short-term security, a costly trade-off that compounds over an entire career. This salary advantage becomes even more pronounced when we examine career advancement opportunities.
2. Career Advancement
The Job Hopping Advantage
When it comes to climbing the corporate ladder, job hopping has typically been the faster route. Each move forces you to take on bigger challenges, expand what you’re responsible for and often land a more senior title. External mobility allows professionals to bypass internal politics, lengthy promotion timelines and organizational hierarchies that might otherwise limit their advancement.
The Job Hugging Reality
Job hugging often means slower advancement, especially at companies with limited growth opportunities or rigid promotion processes. Some organizations are responding to retention concerns with enhanced internal programs, yet the reality is more mixed. Training expenditures in the U.S. declined by 3.7% in 2024, with large companies cutting average spending from $16.1 million in 2023 to $13.3 million in 2024. Many companies are pulling back on development investments rather than expanding them, making internal advancement even more challenging for job huggers.
The Bottom Line
Job hopping offers decisively faster career growth. Each external move typically brings bigger challenges, expanded responsibilities and senior titles that can take years to achieve internally. Job huggers can compete by actively seeking promotions and stretch assignments, but it requires significantly more effort and political navigation. With many companies reducing training investments, moving up internally is becoming harder. These patterns directly shape skill development opportunities.
3. Skill Development
The Job Hopping Advantage
The rapid pace of technological change, particularly AI advancement, has made skill development and marketability more critical than ever. Job hopping traditionally provides:
Exposure to diverse environments and business challenges
Fresh perspectives and different methodologies
Natural expansion of skill sets and adaptability
The Job Hugging Reality
Job hugging presents several challenges for professional development:
Skill stagnation from becoming too comfortable in familiar environments
Limited exposure to new approaches and industry best practices
Reduced marketability in rapidly evolving fields where continuous learning is essential
The current job hugging trend doesn’t have to mean professional stagnation. Among job huggers concerned about AI’s impact, many are already upskilling on AI or automation technologies, showing that awareness of the need for continuous learning is growing.
The Bottom Line
Job hopping wins on skill development through natural exposure to diverse challenges and methodologies. Job huggers face the real risk of skill stagnation and reduced marketability. They can remain competitive by proactively upskilling, but it requires far more intentional effort than the automatic skill expansion that comes with changing roles. These skill differences directly impact job security.
4. Job Security
The Job Hopping Advantage
Job hopping, while feeling riskier in the short term, may actually provide better long-term security through:
Diversified experience across multiple organizations
Expanded professional networks
Broader skill sets that prove valuable during downturns
Greater adaptability and resilience during market changes
The Job Hugging Reality
Job security has become the primary driver behind the job hugging phenomenon, with 95% of job huggers citing concerns about the job market as their main reason for staying put. Yet this perceived security may be an illusion. Corporate loyalty doesn’t guarantee protection from layoffs, as evidenced by the more than 800,000 job eliminations announced by U.S. employers through July 2025. Among job huggers, 59% remain concerned about being laid off, with 84% of those worried workers putting in extra effort to protect their positions.
The Bottom Line
Job hopping delivers superior long-term security through diversified experience and broader professional networks. While job hugging feels safer, it’s essentially an illusion. Job huggers who rely on tenure for protection may find themselves unprepared when market shifts inevitably occur. These security realities directly influence how employers view different career strategies.
5. Employer Perception
The Job Hopping Advantage
Employer perceptions of job hopping have evolved over the past decade. Traditional concerns about job hoppers being disloyal or unreliable have diminished as employers recognize that top talent expects career progression and competitive compensation. Many organizations now view some level of external experience as valuable, bringing fresh perspectives and diverse skill sets.
The Job Hugging Reality
Job hugging presents its own perception challenges. While employers appreciate loyalty and reduced turnover costs, extended tenure without advancement can signal a lack of ambition, limited marketability or complacency. Still, excessive job hopping raises red flags, as employers worry about the cost of hiring and training professionals who may leave quickly.
The Bottom Line
Strategic job hopping with 2 to 4 year tenures is often ideal, showing both commitment and growth. Extended stays without advancement signal complacency, while very short tenures suggest poor judgment. Job huggers must work harder to demonstrate ambition and market value, especially when their lengthy tenure lacks corresponding career progression.
Timing Is Everything
After examining all five critical factors, the evidence points to a clear winner. Job hopping remains the superior long-term career strategy, delivering better salary growth, advancement and resilience—but timing is everything. Today’s job hugging trend, driven by fear rather than strategy, may harm long-term prospects. The best approach is to strengthen your position while staying alert to opportunities, focus on developing AI and automation skills and be selective about career moves. Fear-based decisions rarely succeed. Your career trajectory over the next decade will largely depend on the choices you make in the next two years. Choose strategy over fear.
Want more strategies to take control of your career? Subscribe to my Corporate Escape Artist newsletter for weekly insights.
Editorial StandardsReprints & Permissions
