By Austin Wood

Copyright gamesradar

Skip to main content

GamesRadar+
The Games, Movies, TV & Comics You Love

View Profile

Search GamesRadar+

Game Insights

Games Features

Games Reviews

Games Guides

The Big Preview

On The Radar

Future Games Show

Action Games

Action RPGs

Adventure Games

Third Person Shooters

Xbox Series X

Nintendo Switch

Nintendo Switch 2

Tabletop Gaming

Grand Theft Auto

Assassin’s Creed

Monster Hunter

The Elder Scrolls

Entertainment

Anime Shows

Sci-Fi Shows

Superhero Shows

Animated Shows

Marvel TV Shows

Star Wars TV Shows

DC TV Shows

Movie Reviews

Superhero Movies

Action Movies

Sci-Fi Movies

Anime Movies

Horror Movies

Marvel Movies

Apple TV Plus

Disney Plus

Amazon Prime Video

Marvel Comics

Toys & Merch

Toys & Collectibles

Dungeons and Dragons

Hardware News

Hardware Reviews

Hardware Features

Desktop PCs

Peripherals

Headsets & Headphones

TVs & Monitors

Gaming Mice

Gaming Keyboards

Gaming Chairs

Speakers & Audio

Accessories & Tech

Gaming Controllers

SSDs & Hard Drives

Accessories

Buying Guides

Newsletters

Retro Gamer

Game Insights

Games Features

Games Reviews

Games Guides

The Big Preview

On The Radar

Future Games Show

Action Games

Action RPGs

Adventure Games

Third Person Shooters

View Platforms

Xbox Series X

Nintendo Switch

Nintendo Switch 2

Tabletop Gaming

Franchises

Grand Theft Auto

Assassin’s Creed

Monster Hunter

The Elder Scrolls

Entertainment

View Entertainment

View TV Shows

Anime Shows

Sci-Fi Shows

Superhero Shows

Animated Shows

Marvel TV Shows

Star Wars TV Shows

DC TV Shows

View Movies

Movie Reviews

Superhero Movies

Action Movies

Sci-Fi Movies

Anime Movies

Horror Movies

Marvel Movies

View Streaming

Apple TV Plus

Disney Plus

Amazon Prime Video

View Comics

Marvel Comics

Toys & Merch

Toys & Collectibles

Dungeons and Dragons

View Hardware

Hardware News

Hardware Reviews

Hardware Features

Desktop PCs

Peripherals

View Peripherals

Headsets & Headphones

TVs & Monitors

Gaming Mice

Gaming Keyboards

Gaming Chairs

Speakers & Audio

Accessories & Tech

Gaming Controllers

SSDs & Hard Drives

Accessories

Buying Guides

Newsletters

Retro Gamer

Gaming Magazines

Why subscribe?

Subscribe from just £3
Takes you closer to the games, movies and TV you love
Try a single issue or save on a subscription
Issues delivered straight to your door or device

From£9.99Subscribe now

Dying Light: The Beast
Borderlands 4 review
Battlefield 6
New Games for 2025

Don’t miss these

MMO dev admits egregious microtransactions are “harming” its game, the player base “isn’t really growing,” and it’s time to clean up: “The era of a tainted RuneScape 3 is coming to an end”

MMO community fears PvP bots have formed a “cartel” using false reports to get you banned if you kill them for their illegal loot, bringing Old School RuneScape’s bot problem to a boil

So many World of Warcraft veterans and top streamers are trying Old School RuneScape that even Jagex has noticed, and the gap in MMO muscle memory is hilarious: “Chat I’m freaking out”

“There isn’t FOMO and your progress matters”: An MMO migration turns to revelation for some, with a World of Warcraft horde becoming a wave of RuneScape enjoyers

An anti-FOMO approach would be unthinkable for most MMOs and live service games, but it’s the secret to Old School RuneScape’s new peak of 240,000 players: “Everything you earn matters forever”

10 years later, Old School RuneScape is still the best MMO I’ve ever played – and seeing over 200,000 people jumping on reminds me why I fell in love with it in the first place

When your MMO’s community is “practically forming a religion” based on a big crab, you just go with it: “Oh, the Gemstone Crab’s taken another life. And it’s funny”

Gold is not enough: MMO community declares “Platinum Age” as Old School RuneScape hits 200k players amid WoW migration, dev says “we’ve expanded our live infrastructure to match”

After report on MMO’s bot problem, players bait piles of “clankers” to their doom like they’re poisoning AI: ask “how many” and armies of bots reply in eery unison

“When I explained to her that everyone at Zeke was a real player who came to pay their respects, she burst out in tears”: Parents of late baby son overwhelmed by huge in-game MMO tribute

MMO streamer says he turned down a $5,000 WoW deal to keep grinding Old School RuneScape, player declares “RuneScape won the MMO war” but a dev quickly counters: “You can love both games”

Somehow it took an MMO’s entire community more than 2 years to find an impossibly rare, 1 in 500,000 fishing drop – and after all that, it’s basically worthless

Beaver-collecting mastermind behind 13,000-hour MMO account suggests things got a bit out of hand: “I sort of realized it would be possible to do something unique and stupid and get the most beavers”

This is what MMOs were made for: dev declares “there has been a calamity at the Crab” after 3 hardcore players who purposely gave their characters one life somehow die to a harmless crab boss

MMO history has been made after 21 years: all the blank spaces in the Old School RuneScape map have been filled in for the first time, right as the game hits player count highs

Old School RuneScape

Illegal MMO gold seller earns nearly $500,000, becomes a tax issue, and days later devs announce plans to curb real-world trading

Austin Wood

19 September 2025

Old School RuneScape Lithuanian gold farmers aren’t tax exempt, it appears, while RuneScape law is pretty clear about it

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Jagex / Hi-Rez / YouTube via Xbox)

“‘Gold all doth lure, Gold doth secure all things. Alas, we poor!'”

So begins a recent opinion from EU advocate general Kokott, who faced an unusual situation in a file released on September 11. Lithuanian gold farmers trading ill-gotten gold in the MMO RuneScape – it’s unclear if RuneScape and/or Old School RuneScape specifically were implicated – tried to argue they should be exempt from normal taxes.
Buckle up, folks, because we’re about to litigate gold sellers. Selling gold is flat-out illegal under RuneScape law, but not actually illegal under real-world laws, so it’s trickier than it sounds.

You may like

MMO dev admits egregious microtransactions are “harming” its game, the player base “isn’t really growing,” and it’s time to clean up: “The era of a tainted RuneScape 3 is coming to an end”

MMO community fears PvP bots have formed a “cartel” using false reports to get you banned if you kill them for their illegal loot, bringing Old School RuneScape’s bot problem to a boil

So many World of Warcraft veterans and top streamers are trying Old School RuneScape that even Jagex has noticed, and the gap in MMO muscle memory is hilarious: “Chat I’m freaking out”

“In the present case, the Court has an opportunity to deal with the way in which an entirely new form of gold trading is considered for VAT [value added tax] purposes,” the opinion reads. “A taxable person has managed to ‘turn to gold’ a ‘currency’ designed for an online computer game, in-game Gold, outside the game by purchasing it from players and reselling it to other players.”

The gold sellers in question were “trying to convince the tax authority” that RuneScape gold is either “an exempt ‘currency transaction'” or “at least” a “multi-purpose voucher.” This voucher status could affect how much tax is applied and when it comes due under the VAT Directive.
The operation is described as buying and selling gold, posting on “various forums, groups and platforms such as Facebook, Discord and Skype where most people play online games. An advertisement is created to announce that in-game Gold is for sale, indicating prices and contacts.”
An inspection showed that this operation earned “significant income” between 2021 and 2023, totaling €415,484. That’s about $488,000 USD by current conversions. 2021 was an especially strong year at €199,580 in income.

Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter
Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more
Contact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

(Image credit: Jagex / Hi-Rez)
Because its income exceeded the €45,000 threshold for small businesses under Lithuanian law, “the applicant became liable to pay VAT.”
And “because it had failed to do so, by decision of 9 January 2024, the applicant was ordered to pay VAT in the amount of EUR 46 688,” the opinion adds. The gold seller “disagreed with the decision of the tax authority and lodged a complaint,” which is how we got here.
In a request for a preliminary ruling from the Tax Disputes Commission under the Government of the Republic of Lithuania, this is distilled down to two questions, which are reiterated in the opinion.

You may like

MMO dev admits egregious microtransactions are “harming” its game, the player base “isn’t really growing,” and it’s time to clean up: “The era of a tainted RuneScape 3 is coming to an end”

MMO community fears PvP bots have formed a “cartel” using false reports to get you banned if you kill them for their illegal loot, bringing Old School RuneScape’s bot problem to a boil

So many World of Warcraft veterans and top streamers are trying Old School RuneScape that even Jagex has noticed, and the gap in MMO muscle memory is hilarious: “Chat I’m freaking out”

“Does the sale of ‘Gold’ from the game ‘Runescape’ fall within the scope of the exempt transactions set out in Article 135(1)(e) of [the VAT Directive]?”
And: “If the answer to the first question is in the negative, what should be the taxable value of in-game Gold according to the provisions of the VAT Directive,” essentially meaning, should it be the “total consideration for the sale” of the gold or only the real net profit made from buying low and selling high.
This case caught my eye after RSM UK, an audit and tax consulting firm, weighed in on Kokott’s opinion. It offers a useful summary of the case in a press release citing partner Philip Munn and associate director Marilena Papamarkidou: “[The gold seller] sought to reduce the VAT liability by arguing that the gold was akin to a voucher (and outside the scope of VAT) or a second-hand good (so VAT need only be accounted for on the gross profit).”
As you can imagine, a whole bunch of rules and regulations come into play here, both for EU law and Lithuanian law. There is, importantly, a VAT exemption for “transactions, including negotiation, concerning currency, bank notes and coins used as legal tender.” But it turns out they don’t accept RuneScape gold at stores.

(Image credit: Jagex)
Kokott acknowledges that a prior judgment saw the court “extend the concept of legal tender to bitcoins,” with a focus on transactions in Sweden, and the VAT Directive is not expressly clear about transactions where one legal tender is involved but the other currency is non-legal tender. However, RuneScape gold is distinct from Bitcoin and doesn’t meet this lightened standard of currency either.
In consideration of the relevant tax exemption, Kokott writes: “There can be no question of use solely as a means of payment where a ‘currency’ is used only within a game. In that case, it is not a means of payment, but merely a means within the game, that is to say, play money.” And put simply, play money doesn’t count.
Addressing the voucher classification directly, the opinion rather amusingly adds: “The mere fact that a service (in-game Gold) can be exchanged for another (such as an item like a ‘magic sword’) – in the present case, within the game – does not make the service that has already been supplied a voucher.”
So for now, while the court’s decision remains non-final, it’s looking like this gold seller won’t escape one of the great inevitabilities of life. In conclusion, Kokott proposes that this RuneScape gold is, in fact, “already a consumable benefit” and therefore outside the scope of the VAT tax exemption.
However, there is a fascinating closer. Kokott suggests that cases like this could necessitate updated interpretations of EU tax law. Specifically, relevant articles of the VAT Directive “must be interpreted, in the light of technological developments, in a teleologically broader manner as covering also transferable non-tangible objects, provided that they are traded in legal transactions in the same way as tangible objects.”

(Image credit: Jagex)
The most important quality would be: “Such services are traded on a secondary market in a comparable way to regular second-hand goods and typically contain residual VAT.”
In this case, “It is for the referring commission to determine whether that is the case for in-game Gold.”
RSM puts it this way: “In the meantime, it is clear that VAT law needs to catch up with technological advances and gaming companies must bear in mind that in-app purchase innovation might create unforeseen VAT consequences.”
Here’s the real kicker. Remember, this opinion came on September 11. On September 16, RuneScape and Old School RuneScape developer Jagex announced a sweeping crackdown on real world trading, which is fueled by gold sellers, in both games.
“For as long as RuneScape has been around, a disappointing number of players have sought unfair advantages by buying in-game gold directly off illicit sellers,” the developer wrote.
“This rule-breaking doesn’t just affect the player who’s buying the gold. It creates a financial incentive for people who don’t care about the game to flood it with bots and throw-away accounts to gather gold to sell. So, when legitimate players gather items to sell on the GE [marketplace], they’ll earn less because the market’s affected by botted resources, and playing alongside all the highly visible bots is infuriating!”
With this in mind, Jagex said it is redoubling its work to address the “demand-side” of gold selling, not just the suppliers doing the botting and farming, by escalating punishments for buying gold. The developer threatened bans that may be permanent, and said it will be “confiscating items from the offenders.” This isn’t entirely new, but Jagex is stepping up its efforts, and I’ve seen reports in the RuneScape community of a recent wave of real world trading punishments.
Now, I don’t know for sure if Jagex was actually motivated in part by this EU opinion – and I’ve reached out to the company for comment – but I do know the timing of the gold seller and magic sword litigation is absolutely hilarious.
Hundreds of MMO players show up to support a father mourning his infant son, who shares a name with an NPC in Old School RuneScape: “We have such an incredible community with the biggest hearts”

See more PC Gaming News

Austin Wood

Social Links Navigation
Senior writer

Austin has been a game journalist for 12 years, having freelanced for the likes of PC Gamer, Eurogamer, IGN, Sports Illustrated, and more while finishing his journalism degree. He’s been with GamesRadar+ since 2019. They’ve yet to realize his position is a cover for his career-spanning Destiny column, and he’s kept the ruse going with a lot of news and the occasional feature, all while playing as many roguelikes as possible.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

MMO dev admits egregious microtransactions are “harming” its game, the player base “isn’t really growing,” and it’s time to clean up: “The era of a tainted RuneScape 3 is coming to an end”

MMO community fears PvP bots have formed a “cartel” using false reports to get you banned if you kill them for their illegal loot, bringing Old School RuneScape’s bot problem to a boil

So many World of Warcraft veterans and top streamers are trying Old School RuneScape that even Jagex has noticed, and the gap in MMO muscle memory is hilarious: “Chat I’m freaking out”

“There isn’t FOMO and your progress matters”: An MMO migration turns to revelation for some, with a World of Warcraft horde becoming a wave of RuneScape enjoyers

An anti-FOMO approach would be unthinkable for most MMOs and live service games, but it’s the secret to Old School RuneScape’s new peak of 240,000 players: “Everything you earn matters forever”

10 years later, Old School RuneScape is still the best MMO I’ve ever played – and seeing over 200,000 people jumping on reminds me why I fell in love with it in the first place

Latest in MMO Games

Elder Scrolls Online leads say Elder Scrolls 6 and Oblivion Remastered only bolster the MMO’s player numbers: “We saw a lot of new and lapsed players”

“When I explained to her that everyone at Zeke was a real player who came to pay their respects, she burst out in tears”: Parents of late baby son overwhelmed by huge in-game MMO tribute

Hundreds of MMO players show up to support a father mourning his infant son, who shares a name with an NPC in Old School RuneScape: “We have such an incredible community with the biggest hearts”

Final Fantasy 14 is getting a “big update” to bring out the “uniqueness of each job” in battle content, Yoshi-P says, before confusingly adding “that nothing is going to change” for those who like things the way they are

26 years after dead MMO was left to rot, YouTuber spends 30 days reviving it through sheer will: “You reignited a fire that never went out, now it burns brighter than ever,” devs say

Sega’s crunch was so bad, offices came equipped with nap rooms and showers until 2012: “It was basically expected that people would be sleeping over at the office”

Latest in News

The demo for the follow-up to one of the best indie action RPGs ever is now on Steam, and folks, Alabaster Dawn might be even better than CrossCode

Illegal MMO gold seller earns nearly $500,000, becomes a tax issue, and days later devs announce plans to curb real-world trading

Indie game goes viral for turning Fallout 3’s VATS system into an incredible anime action sequence where you steal limbs instead of just targeting them

FromSoftware finally added an easy button to one of its games: Elden Ring Nightreign will let you de-rank its brutal Deep of Night mode if you decide it’s too hard

2TB Xbox Series X will soon be $800 as Microsoft ups US console prices for the second time in 5 months, making a PS5 Pro look downright affordable

Silksong player clears Team Cherry’s smokescreen and calculates the damage of every Crest, proving I was absolutely right to stick with Wanderer the whole game

GAME REVIEWS
MOVIE REVIEWS

Dying Light: The Beast review – “A playful sandbox of horror and mayhem with a surprising amount of depth”

Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds review: “Even more frantic than Mario Kart World, this has the mileage to be a karting favorite”

Lego Voyagers review: “A carefully crafted, playful, and earnest adventure”

There’s now a real version of the Witcher Gwent card game, and it’s just as engrossing as the original

Borderlands 4 review: “Undeniably an excellent looter shooter, but one that requires a bit of tunnel vision to fully enjoy”

One Battle After Another review: “One of the best studio movies in years and an instant classic”

The Conjuring: Last Rites review: “Not bold or memorable enough for the Warrens’ final chapter”

Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle review: “Roars past Mugen Train as Demon Slayer’s best adventure yet”

The Long Walk review: “One of the best Stephen King adaptations ever made”

Frankenstein review: “A classy, if somewhat safe, adaptation”

Gen V season 2 review: “As strong as the first season, if not stronger”

Wednesday season 2 part 2 review: “Ortega shines, but it’s a zombie who steals the entire show”

Peacemaker season 2 review: “Darker and sadder than the first year, but there’s still a lot of fun to be had with the 11th Street Kids.”

Wednesday season 2 part 1 review: “Complex and exciting but weighed down by too many subplots”

Alien: Earth review: “Arguably the franchise’s strongest outing since James Cameron’s Aliens”

GamesRadar+ is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

Contact Future’s experts

Terms and conditions

Privacy policy

Cookies policy

Advertise with us

Review guidelines

Write for us

Accessibility Statement

Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury,

BA1 1UA. All rights reserved. England and Wales company registration number 2008885.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait…