Write to us at startingpoint@globe.com. To subscribe, sign up here.
A growing number of teachers and staff across the country, including in Massachusetts, have faced professional discipline after they posted celebratory or negative comments over the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
At least a half dozen public school teachers and staff in Massachusetts have been disciplined for what they’ve said online about Kirk, who was posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom on Tuesday. The same day, the State Department revoked at least six visas of foreigners over criticism of Kirk.
The Massachusetts school districts that have announced such disciplinary moves cite concerns over such issues as student safety, the potential distress caused by insensitive and inflammatory comments, and the need for maintaining institutional values.
The short answer on school discipline, according to First Amendment advocates, may be no.
“The murder of Charlie Kirk was a tragedy. Government officials should not exploit that tragedy, however, to censor political speech they don’t like,” said Alex Abdo, litigation director of the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University.
Free speech protections can be limited if the speech could damage or disrupt the workplace, First Amendment experts said. But in such cases, school officials and the courts must weigh whether any potential damage outweighs the speech’s value.
That damage could include a teacher’s inability to interact with colleagues after a post, lead a class, or interact with parents and students, as well as whether students feel safe and supported, First Amendment specialists said.
Speech that causes some disruption isn’t enough to limit freedom of speech, said Justin Silverman, executive director of the New England First Amendment Coalition, a nonprofit advocacy organization. “I can’t overstate how much protection political speech is given by the First Amendment,” he said.
President Trump has also applied pressure on those who have made public statements that he opposes, from media companies and law firms to entertainers including Jimmy Kimmel. Last month, Trump also suggested TV networks should have their licenses taken away because they “give me only bad publicity.”
Last month, a federal judge in Massachusetts criticized the Trump administration’s crackdown on the free speech rights of foreign students who were demonstrating in support of Palestinian rights.
And last week, Trump falsely claimed that he “took the freedom of speech away” for people who burn the US flag, saying he made doing so a crime.
It’s unclear how Trump’s crackdown on freedom of speech will affect the nation’s schools long term.
Death threats and promises of violence have escalated against American educators after Kirk’s death, according to officials with the Massachusetts Teachers Association, which said it is watching these free speech cases closely. Last week, a Rutgers professor who studies antifascism fled the country after death threats.
And Trump has made a point of tightening control over the nation’s public education system, including its K-12 schools. That has included a crackdown on issues including rights for transgender students and elimination of diversity, equity, and inclusion programs. And Trump has pressured universities to sign agreements pledging they’ll go along with his priorities, or risk losing federal funding. (Brown University rejected that pledge yesterday, joining MIT.)
In schools, students would benefit by protecting free speech, argued Jeffrey Pyle, a First Amendment lawyer and partner at Prince Lobel in Boston.
“I think the public and students benefit when their teachers are willing to talk about public issues, even if it means they might be misunderstood or they might be offended,” he said.
Material from past Globe stories was used in this report.
More on Kirk: Kirk’s slaying sparked a surge of interest, social media followers, and donations to his movement. Will it last?
🧩 3 Down: Reef material | ⛅ 55° Blustery
Regatta revamp: This year’s Head of the Charles, which begins tomorrow, will feature food, a DJ, lounge seating, activities for kids, and in-boat livestreaming in a bid to draw spectators beyond rowing fans.
Leak fallout: Vermont officials of both parties called for a GOP state senator, who is also the state’s Young Republicans chair, to resign over racist comments he allegedly made in a private group chat.
Local landmark: Boston will slightly reposition its iconic CITGO sign in Kenmore Square as part of a redevelopment project. Mayor Michelle Wu called it an effort “to preserve this iconic sign for generations to come.”
Sex abuse scandal: New Hampshire’s Supreme Court blocked a lawsuit accusing the Catholic diocese there of failing to protect summer campers in the 1970s, ruling that a now-repealed statute of limitations on child sex abuse claims still applies retroactively.
Housing divided: In Newton, an affordable housing developer is buying an aging apartment building and will subsidize rents using city money. In Charlestown, a concrete manufacturer is pushing back on a planned 705-unit residential building.
No sanctuary: Along Vermont’s northern border, a rural county sheriff is increasingly at odds with a state policy limiting law enforcement from cooperating with federal immigration authorities.
Pulled pork: Citing fiscal uncertainty, Governor Maura Healey’s administration will indefinitely withhold tens of millions in earmarks for lawmakers’ local projects.
Charged: The authorities charged five men in connection with the assault of a gay couple in Mattapan last month. All five pleaded not guilty to various assault and battery charges.
Geography lesson: Massachusetts Democrats scoffed at Trump’s threat to “take away” 2026 World Cup matches from the state because of crime in Boston, noting that the games are set to be played about an hour away in Foxborough.
Sue with Parkinson’s: A Harvard professor hid her diagnosis from administrators, colleagues, and students, secretly recording her symptoms in video diaries. Now she’s going public to help others cope with the disease. (NYT 🎁)
By David Beard
📺 Donnie Wahlberg’s challenge: In the new TV series “Boston Blue,” the Bostonian plays a New York cop named Danny adjusting to Boston. “It’s a very unique position to be in, loving Boston in my heart, not loving Boston in Danny’s heart,” he tells Meredith Goldstein.
🤰Surprise: This 46-year-old mom thought she had menopause. But she was pregnant.
🐀 Rat neighborhoods: Boston rodent reports are way up — and here’s where they’re most common.
🎂 Happy 100th! Today’s Wang Theatre began as a silent movie palace, then a smoky rock club, and later home to everything from The Nutcracker to the Grateful Dead. And it’s still hopping!
🍁 Last lap for fall foliage: Here are New England’s best and brightest leaves now.
📻 Kiss off 108? Amid listener uproar, radio morning show hosts address the unpopular firing of Winnie Akoury.
🧛 Vampire graves! Yes, that and a purported UFO abduction site are among these 13 creepy places in New England.
Thanks for reading Starting Point.
This newsletter was edited by David Beard and Ian Prasad Philbrick.
❓ Have a question for the team? Email us at startingpoint@globe.com.
✍🏼 If someone sent you this newsletter, you can sign up for your own copy.
📬 Delivered Monday through Friday.