The Buffalo Bills no longer can rely on Matt Milano.
That’s a harsh reality, but it is one the team’s coaching staff has to accept after the linebacker suffered yet another injury during Sunday’s loss to the New England Patriots at Highmark Stadium.
On Monday, head coach Sean McDermott classified Milano as “week to week” with a pectoral injury. Milano originally suffered the injury in Week 2 against the New York Jets, which kept him out of the second half of that game and the next two. He returned to play the first half against the Patriots before again being sidelined.
Milano now has missed the equivalent of three of the Bills’ five games this season, the continuation of a troubling trend that dates back to Week 5 of the 2023 season. It was during that season that Milano suffered a devastating leg injury in a game against the Jacksonville Jaguars in London, knocking him out for the remainder of the year. A torn bicep muscle suffered in training camp in summer 2024 sidelined Milano for the first 11 games of the regular season. He returned to play in three before missing another one because of a groin injury.
Put simply, it has been one thing after another … after another … after another.
White has allowed 12 catches on 15 targets for 119 yards, 9.9 yards per reception, and one touchdown. He doesn’t have the speed to keep up with the league’s best, Lysowski says.
“That’s what it’s been from the standpoint of his injuries the last two or three years,” head coach Sean McDermott conceded. “I don’t want that for him. Nobody wants that for him. Nobody works harder than Matt Milano to stay healthy. So, right now, it’s going to be a next man up for this week, and we’ll take it one day and apparently, now, one week at a time, and just see where it goes.”
Those couldn’t have been easy words for McDermott to speak. Milano was part of the 2017 draft class, meaning he has been with McDermott from the beginning of the coach’s run in Buffalo. When the new Highmark Stadium opens in 2026, Milano figures to one day be honored as one of the great players in franchise history, in whatever form that takes.
A first-team All-Pro in 2022, Milano ranks fourth in franchise history since 1999 with 60 tackles for loss. He’s 10th in that same time frame with 39 passes defended, while his 42 quarterback hits ranks 12th. For a long, long time, whenever the defense needed an impact play – whether it was a timely takeaway or a must tackle – Milano was the guy to make it.
McDermott ruled out the possibility of Milano going on injured reserve, “at this point,” meaning the team believes he will be able to return in less than the required four-game absence a stint on IR necessitates.
But if and when he does come back, then what? How can the coaching staff build a game plan around having Milano on the field, knowing full well he hasn’t been able to stay there?
After Sunday’s 23-20 loss to the New England Patriots, Buffalo Bills coach Sean McDermott lamented that the Bills might have been “too cute” at times.
Listen now and subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | RSS Feed | SoundStack
They can’t, and they shouldn’t.
Dorian Williams proved capable in Milano’s absence last season, although he is dealing with a knee injury at the moment that kept him out of Week 5. The team signed veteran Shaq Thompson in the offseason, and he has been impactful in the first five games – both on the field and in the locker room as a leader. The coaching staff has to have an honest conversation about whether either of them can be a more trusted, reliable option than Milano at this point in their respective careers.
The Bills have played 39 games, including the playoffs, since that trip to London. Milano has missed all but 10 of them, meaning he has been available less than 25% of the time – a percentage that is even lower when you consider the games he has started, but has been unable to finish.
“I know it’s really tough on him,” defensive coordinator Bobby Babich said. “On a personal level, the guy does everything right, when you talk about taking care of your body, all those type of things.”
There is no reason to doubt that is true. The Bills have raved about how Milano has approached his rehab. He has done everything he can to stay on the field … but it hasn’t been enough.
Time after time during the Bills’ first loss of the season, quarterback Josh Allen dropped back to pass, but had nowhere to go with the ball. Outside of tight end Dalton Kincaid, who had a career-best 108 receiving yards on six receptions, the Bills receivers simply didn’t look to be open often enough for Allen.
That has to take a psychological toll.
“No matter what the circumstance is, don’t let negativity creep in your head, right? Because, to me, there’s a little bit of, ‘That doesn’t help the healing process, at all,’ ” Babich said. “So, we’re going to continue to take it day by day and keep Matt positive. I know he’ll do everything he can to be out there. … All these guys want to play. They play this game because they love it and it brings them joy, and to not be out there is not fun.”
Babich said he has never seen any of that negativity creep into Milano’s process.
The same can’t be said for the fan base. Reaction to the linebacker’s latest injury on social media has been mostly filled with frustration, which is the nicest way of putting it.
More bluntly, they’ve had enough of the injuries.
It’s time to start wondering if the team has, too. The Bills reworked Milano’s contract in the offseason, shaving a year off it and making him an unrestricted free agent after this season. At 31, and with his recent injury history, it was very much a prove-it deal. As in, prove that he can stay healthy and be a difference-maker for the defense.
Five weeks into the season, Milano has proven otherwise.
Get in the game with our Prep Sports Newsletter
Sent weekly directly to your inbox!
* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.
Jay Skurski
News Sports Reporter
Get email notifications on {{subject}} daily!
Your notification has been saved.
There was a problem saving your notification.
{{description}}
Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items.
Followed notifications
Please log in to use this feature
Log In
Don’t have an account? Sign Up Today