By Justin Rimpi,Total Apex Sports

Copyright yardbarker

Let’s be real here – this firing shouldn’t shock anyone who’s been paying attention. Melvin walked into his dream job two years ago, talking about full-circle moments and childhood fantasies of managing his beloved Giants. The 63-year-old Palo Alto native probably thought he was going to ride off into the sunset with another World Series ring. Instead, he’s riding off into unemployment with a 161-163 record that screams “aggressively average.”

The irony? The Giants actually picked up Melvin’s contract option for 2026 back in July, essentially saying, “Hey Bob, we love what you’re doing!” Then they promptly traded away half their bullpen and watched the season implode like a controlled demolition in slow motion.

When Dreams Become Nightmares

Remember when this Giants team was supposed to compete? Buster Posey threw around $380 million like he was playing Monopoly with fake money, bringing in Willy Adames, Justin Verlander, and even trading for Rafael Devers mid-season. For a hot minute in June, they were tied atop the NL West, looking like world-beaters.

Then reality hit harder than a Nolan Ryan fastball. The Giants went on a brutal 9-25 stretch that had fans questioning their life choices and Melvin looking like he’d rather be anywhere else – maybe back in Oakland, where at least the expectations were properly managed.

The Ultimate Roller Coaster Season

This 2025 campaign had more ups and downs than a Six Flags ride. Just when you thought the Giants were dead and buried, they rattled off 14 wins in 18 games, suddenly finding themselves back in the wild-card hunt. Patrick Bailey’s walk-off grand slam against the Dodgers on September 12 had the fanbase believing in miracles again.

But as quickly as hope arrived, it vanished. The Giants collapsed faster than a house of cards in a hurricane, losing nine of their next 11 games and getting officially eliminated with four games still on the schedule. That’s not just disappointing – that’s downright heartbreaking for a fanbase that’s been through enough pain to last several lifetimes.

Posey’s First Big Move As the Boss

This marks Posey’s first major decision as president of baseball operations, and boy, what a statement. The former catcher-turned-executive isn’t messing around. He inherited Melvin from the Farhan Zaidi era but clearly saw enough to know a change was necessary.

Now Posey gets to handpick his own manager – the sixth in the Oracle Park era. Names are already floating around faster than Barry Bonds’ home run balls: Skip Schumaker, Mark DeRosa, Brandon Hyde, and hey, maybe even Bruce Bochy if he’s feeling nostalgic for some championship magic.

The Human Element

You can’t help but feel for Melvin on a human level. This was supposed to be his swan song, his final managing gig with the team he grew up loving. Matt Chapman practically said he signed with the Giants because of Melvin. Adames wanted to play for him throughout his entire Giants tenure.

But baseball is ultimately a results business, and Melvin didn’t deliver the results. Three consecutive years of finishing last in stolen bases, fundamental baseball mistakes that made Little League coaches cringe, and a bullpen that got decimated by trades – it all added up to a pink slip.

The Giants organization now faces its fourth manager in four seasons, a level of instability that would make even the most dysfunctional franchises blush. But sometimes you’ve got to break a few eggs to make an omelet, and Posey clearly believes this particular egg needed breaking.