An enthralling contest at Bethpage Black in the latest instalment of the Ryder Cup saw Team Europe edge Team USA 15-13, after it seemed for much of the encounter that the visitors were set to run away with the trophy.
The Americans looked determined to make an unprecedented recovery heading into the final day, a mammoth seven points down, which no team has been able to overturn in history, though, an admirable effort fell just short. The result, meanwhile, has not halted the reactions of both sets of players.
A big talking point from the weekend’s action was the use of an old rule that has been in place since 1979, and one, used for just the third time in that period, that has evoked different reactions out of both captains, rather predictably.
It was in fact used in the final round of action on Sunday. Europe’s Viktor Hovland had to withdraw with a neck injury. Therefore, scheduled singles opponent, Harris English, had to sit out in what can be seen as an unfortunate turn of events for Team USA, who needed maximum points to recover on the final day.
Captain Keegan Bradley bemoaned the infamous envelope rule, which requires each captain to put the name of a golfer in an envelope in the case of an injury or withdrawal to an opposing player, urging the need for a change ahead of the next Ryder Cup in 2027.
It frankly is a rule that can go both ways, evidenced by the two previous occasions it has been called into use. In 1991, it fell favourably for the US when Steve Pate was unable to compete further, likewise for Europe just two years later, when Sam Torrance withdrew.
Bradley noted his frustrations after a gutting defeat to Team Europe, alluding to solutions of his own.
What Keegan Bradley Has Said About Ryder Cup Rule
“It has to change. I have a few ideas, but I’m not going to tell you right now. It’s obvious to everybody in the sports world, in this room. Nothing against Viktor. But that rule needs to change by the next Ryder Cup.”
It will remain unclear how proceedings could have differed had the match between English and Hovland gone ahead. Momentum certainly would have continued to build for the Americans had they secured victory in that match, though, with just a one-point swing on the line, the final result would not have changed.
Luke Donald Disagrees With Keegan Bradley
Team Europe’s captain, Luke Donald, however, defended the rule’s existence, stating: “The rule is the rule, and it’s been in place for a long time. We have contracts for a reason, a captains’ agreement for a reason, for situations that occur.”
It may raise some needed questions and the opportunity to improve how the rule does come into play, whether it is right or wrong, with injuries ultimately being a significant part of any sport that the decision-makers cannot envision.
The reaction from both captains are understandable, but frankly, will continue to provoke differing responses whether it aids a victory or puts one team at a disadvantage. Think of it like a refereeing decision in football. If one team is trailing and a decision goes against them, even if it is right, they will protest it. Such is the nature of sports and competition.
Time will tell whether the rule will see change, or further action. The lawmakers, meanwhile, have two years to listen to the competitors and ponder a decision that could have major future implications in the Ryder Cup.